Not Your Sugar Mama's


Bakers Kyleen Keenan and Bennett Coffey of Not Your Sugar Mama’s - Martha’s Vineyard, MA

32 Winter Street Edgartown, MA 02539
Martha's Vineyard, MA 02359
(508) 834-7305
Hours: Mon-Sun7am-10pm

The Sugar Mamas’ raw chocolate has depth of flavor similar to dark chocolate, contains an energizing array of nutrients including magnesium, and is in all their wares: pastries, powders, syrups, and their chocolate bars such as "Be Sexy"—just get 'em while they're cold, they melt fast! Kyleen Kenan and Bennett Coffey are self-taught and self-styled businesswomen, chocolatiers, and sugar mamas who produce a vast array of raw chocolate products, baked goods, and healthy vibrations. Kenan and Coffey have blended a tiki bar aesthetic with that of a surf shop and swapped the piña coladas for raw chocolate-avocado smoothies. Surf boards have been traded in for chocolate bars and gluten free cookies, cup cakes, and scones at the two Not Your Sugar Mamas Martha’s Vineyard locations in Vineyard Haven and Edgartown.

Recommended Dishes:
  • “Be Kookie:” Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookie
  • "Be Vibrant" Smoothie: Avocado, Banana, Goji Berries, Spinach, Strawberries, Raw Cacao, Mesquite, and Chlorophyll

  • + Click image to enlarge