|  home | feedback | help          
A Conversation with Dan Barber

By Tejal Rao
September 2007

Tejal Rao: You came across Eliot Colemanís writing as an undergrad at Tufts and he allowed you to look at cooking and farming in a different way. Was there a moment when it all came together?

Dan Barber: Yes, but the reason his writing really spoke to me is because I grew up spending time on Blue Hill Farm, my grandmotherís farm. I worked there Ė thatís how I spent my time growing up. My grandmother wasnít a farmer, so to speak, but weíre talking about 200 acres of pasture land Ė she was a land activist, really keen on preserving open spaces and keeping a country feel. Her agricultural philosophy was about pleasure Ė pleasure in terms of sight and by way of responsibility.

When I got into college, I read Coleman. Here was a guy saying, not directly, but indirectly, the same thing. I thought about pleasure in terms of taste by way of responsibility. It spoke to me because my grandmother spoke to me first. Food meant more than cooking, more than pleasure. Itís so much attached to how we buy and grow, and whoís growing it and how itís getting to you. This is a big part of the experience of being a chef.

TR: Your writing is fantastic; how did you get into it?

DB: Thank you. I donít know, I was an English major Ė English and Political Science. I saw how food issues could be at once poetic and political. In food, issues that surround purchasing and that whole realm have a very political component and they branch into stories that can be really compelling. Just being on the farm, interacting with all these people in the industry, leads to personal narratives that can be used to make a larger point.

TR: Tell me about Stone Barns Centerís greenhouse; itís really cool.

DB: Oh yeah, the greenhouse is really the heart and soul of the project. Itís hard to be as passionate about it as I normally would be, say in the winter, because Jack Algiere and his crew have 6Ĺ acres of outdoor production going on right now…

TR: Because it is only used for cold weather growing?

DB: Yes, mostly, but whatís really great about it is that we can use it for, say, arugula this time of year. The arugula doesnít bolt or get bitter because certain UV rays canít get in. But yes, the real reason for building it, initially, was to allow the farm to have revenue 12 months of the year. Farming in the Northeast is very difficult, and Westchester County is particularly hard.

TR: Why?

DB: Well, the weather. We have a great 5 month growing season but then the rest of the year the land is dormant. If you run something through the greenhouse at least you can break even in January/February/March and, partly, provide food for the restaurant. Jack doesnít grow, for example, tomatoes, in the middle of winter just because I want them on the menu. He picks winter vegetables that require the least amount of fossil fuel possible Ė like salad greens and cold winter vegetables Ė that thrive in cold weather. Also, theyíve got to grow quickly Ė 6-8 weeks Ė because fast turnover means fast revenue and itís truly driven by economics and flavor.

TR: So it's all about economics and flavor.

DB: Actually, no, the greenhouse is driven by three things:
Where ecology is whatís being grown in this micro-ecology that can simultaneously thrive and better the soil/rotation, not just the flavor. If you just think exclusively about what would be the best tasting or the most profitable, youíre just not seeing the big picture. In the greenhouse, all three work in tandem. It took me a while to understand this, but when I think about it today, I think you canít have great flavor and bad ecology. Theyíre inextricably connected.

TR: How did you learn about this Ė did you have a farming mentor of some sort or was it trial and error?

DB: Eliot Coleman, actually! He was the Four Season Farmís master planner. I called him because I really wanted to meet him Ė Iíd been to his lectures and read his books, and Iíve even written to him but he never wrote me backÖ Finally, we reached out to him and said, hereís a real opportunity. He got into it really quickly; heís a large part of why my family is so involved now.

TR: Pastoral photography is the new pastoral poetry. The pictures of you on the farm are very pretty, very romantic Ė but you spent a lot of time on your farm; you knew what was involved.

DB: Yes, for me there was very little romance. The pay-off was simply open space. I canít stress it enough: the farm is all open pasture. The reality of caring for it isnít a drudgery but I always keep in mind that land degrades when itís not cared for. It takes time and energy and passion to maintain it, and it becomes a way Ė the way Ė to connect back to the food.

TR: Was it ever so hard you wanted to do something else?

DB: Iím not sure what you meanÖ

TR: I mean, working in kitchens. I quit after 2 years Ė I think itís another thing thatís romanticized to no end and turns out to be really hard. Did you ever think youíd do something else instead?

DB: Oh yes, I think that everyday. Everyday something goes awry. I mean, look, you know how much can go wrong in a kitchen so you can imagine when that restaurant is so closely linked to a farm how much more can actually go wrong. You take those disappointments and times them by 2 and you become even more sensitive to them. Some days, I feel that way. But at the same time I donít know if this has any kind of legitimacy. Iím very close to it, too close to it even, to give an unbiased opinion. Letís be honest; itís a dream.

TR: It is. Whatís going on in those 6Ĺ acres right now?

DB: September: tomatoes galore. Jack and his crew are harvesting about 1000 pounds a week. Weíve got about 30 varieties this summer between Blue Hill Farm and Stone Barns. Weíve got broccoli and cauliflower going and weíre doing experiments with older varieties Ė thereís this pura cassava broccoli right now that was basically the grandfather of modern broccoli. Itís incredibly misshapen - standard broccoli is so bulked up and uniform and much lighter in color. This is more broccoli rabe-esque and it has a more interesting flavor. Itís more complex, not necessarily sweeter, and when you bite into it itís like youíre getting 10 times the amount of broccoli flavor.

TR: Where do the farmers get the seeds?

DB: Jack got these seeds from a friend whoís a farmer but we generally get them from all over Ė catalog companies sometimes. With garlic and shallots though, we create our own. Weíre letting them go to seed and then planting them ourselves.

TR: What about Stone Barnsí animals?

DB: We can control the future generations of the pig by having a boar and sow mate, picking and choosing the parents based on the specific characteristics we want to continue. I think what Craig Haney, the Center's Livestock Manager, is doing is stunning, I mean, they do have hiccups Ė consistency issues Ė but they can start to work these out when thereís genetic control. Itís amazing.

TR: So what sort of characteristics are you trying to carry on?

DB: There arenít a lot of people who buy and raise pigs these days. Generally, the way it happens, is farmers will get a large number of stock of feeder pigs, young piglets, from Iowa and then bring them back to their farm to raise them. Later, theyíll sell them at farmers markets. There arenít a lot of farmers that breed their own Ė or at least, there are fewer and fewer of them.

TR: Why?

DB: Because people use frozen boar sperm to artificially inseminate the sows Ė ďboars in a bottle,Ē thatís what they call them.

TR: ThatísÖso gross.

DB: Seriously, the websites for these things are like pig porn Ė the whole industry is just pathetic. And the thing is, you donít really know what youíre getting. You can go on the site and pick out the boar you want but in the end you still donít really know what youíre getting. You have very little control. But, to answer the question, there are only a few factors to making great pork. One is diet, another one is location (is it moving around and creating flavor), and the last is genetics. In many ways genetics is the most important one for a chef. Of course, so is the diet and the pigsí general sense of happiness but genetics is number one. You can practice old style genetic manipulation with a natural process. If you take a sow that looks like itís doing really well and find a boar thatís got good characteristics then, naturally, the next generation will have them too. That generally leads to better flavor and better marbling.

TR: Is that what youíre really looking for, marbling?

DB: At the end of the day, yes. Itís all about the marbling and maybe a few other things along the way. But intramuscular fat, thatís where you get a lot of flavor. Fat carries the flavor but in the last 50 years itís been bred out of pigs. When American chicken exploded in the 70ís and became such a huge commodity, it took away pork sales. The pork industry suffered and had to change Ė get leaner, reinvent itself -

TR: - as the other white meat.

DB: Right. The national taste veered towards lean beef and chicken and we developed an entirely new breed of pig. And the thing is, once you start breeding a pig for less fat, you canít keep it outside anymore. This new pig canít regulate its body fat so it canít survive the cold. Then the pig has to live inside because thereís a physical imperative for it.

TR: But youíre bringing it back out.

DB: Weíre achieving better marbling and better flavor with old world wisdom thatís been passed down for generations but weíre still using technology. In the case of the pigs, we keep a sonogram machine on the farm and run it over the sowís backside to get a reading of its distribution of fat and marbling.

TR: Thatís amazing!

DB: I try to talk about a farm/chef/restaurant that utilizes old world heritage wisdom and expertise (which these farmers have in abundance) and marrying it with technology to bring it into a modern context. If youíre a purist, might look at it as techno glitz ridiculousness, but you can have better tasting meat through technology so why not? Sustainability doesnít mean ignoring innovation and modern applications.

TR: I read this review of The Fat Badger by Giles Coren where he goes on about mineral water and calls it a ďpreposterous vanity.Ē And heís actually made it a category that he grades just as he would cooking and service, insisting that if itís served at all it better be local. What are your thoughts?

DB: Thatís great, Iíd love to read it. We use Keepers Spring which bottles local water. Itís completely non-profit; it was started by Kennedy JR to profit local water sources. And itís delicious.

TR: Plastic bottles that never decompose? Glass bottles too heavy to freight?

DB: Sure, thereís a compromise. But on the other hand, all profit goes to maintaining clean water in our region, so itís great.

TR: Almond carrots and almond fennel. In your story the carrots you and Jack grew in almond powder donít taste like almonds but somehow, that doesnít come across as a failure. What about the fennel Ė howís that working out?

DB: You tell me when you come in; weíre getting better and better at it. Within a couple of weeks we should have it figured out. Recently, we did it and it looks like it will actually work for the first time Ė but you need tons and tons of the dust.

TR: Your grandmotherís old farm in Massachusetts, is it a dairy operation now for your cheese-making? I read about it once but canít seem to find anything more about it.

DB: Not yet, weíre making milk though and the milk is unbelievable. It was a dairy farm for 120 years, then it became a cattle grazing farm with my grandmother, and now weíve returned it to dairy. We have about 22 dairy cows and weíve hired a farmer, Sean Stanton.

TR: Are you selling it?

DB: Right now weíre making a lot of butter and ricotta cheese, just for the restaurant. But ultimately, within the next year, we want to make the cheese.

TR: What kinds of cheeses do you want to make?

DB: Weíre testing out the breeds to see what works best; weíve got about 5 or 6 breeds right now and itís going to take a while to figure out. But thatís the future of Blue Hill Farm. My brother and I want it to be more than Stone Barns Ė we want to start raising cattle.

TR: So, Stone Barns is a not-for-profit founded by David Rockefeller (who provided the initial 30 million dollar investment into the project); I know you have to start turning a profit after three years, hasnít it been three years?

DB: Yeah, itís been just about 3 years. The farm and the restaurant are doing really well. In fact, we were really lucky and started turning a profit in the restaurant within our first year. But when you look at the gestalt of the thing, the focus is non-profit educational work and weíre working to build it up, supported by community. Rockefellerís basic premise was, Iím building the place but it needs to work on its own in the future. And for us to do all of the stuff we do, it requires money Ė weíre trying to balance it with income from the restaurant and farm, but also through memberships, grants, and donations.

TR: If you could go anywhere in the world for dinner tonight, where would it be?

DB: I need to think about it for a secondÖ I think it would be Michel Bras Ė Iíve read so much about it.

TR: So what else is going on?

DB: Because so many chefs are doing innovative things in their kitchens, I feel like thereís an opportunity to translate that kind of creativity to agriculture. With respect to our heritage and old world wisdom, we can push things in directions they havenít been before. You look at a recipe and look at a dish, and traditionally you can break it down into ingredients, but what I would like do is dial back one step farther and break the ingredients into their components. What they ate before they became mise en place. That kind of thinking is provocative for me Ė itís an exciting future if thatís where weíre going.

  • Polyface Farms
  • International Chefs Congress

  •  Sign up for our newsletters!|Print this page|Email this page to a friend
     QuickMeals   Chefs   Rising Stars   Hospitality Jobs   Find a School   Wine   Community   Features   Food Events   News   Ask the Experts   Tickets   Cookbooks
    About Us | Career Opportunities | Media Kit | StarChefs in the News | Site Map
    Please help keep StarChefs a free service by displaying our button on your website. Click here for details.
      Copyright © 1995-2014 StarChefs. All rights reserved.  | Privacy Policy